Review roundup
Davidoff Nicaragua review: the ratings by size, and what the box-pressed blend changes
Twelve years of critic scores and Davidoff's own notes, size by size, for every Davidoff Nicaragua we carry.
The quick answer
Cigar Aficionado's ratings database holds 29 scores for Davidoff Nicaragua since 2013, from 86 to 95. Two sizes reached No. 3 on its Top 25: the Toro for 2013 and the Diadema for 2022. The latest score for each size we carry runs from 86 to 90. Critics' notes keep coming back to coffee, chocolate, nuts, wood and spice. They split on strength, from mild to medium-full, depending on the reviewer and the year. The Box Pressed is a different, stronger blend, and critics split on whether it's an improvement. If you're new to the line, start with a round size. The Diadema is the most-rated size in that database, with seven of its eight scores there at 90 or above.
In this article
What Davidoff Nicaragua is
Davidoff released Davidoff Nicaragua in the summer of 2013 in three sizes: Short Corona, Robusto and Toro. It was the company's first cigar made entirely from Nicaraguan tobacco and the first Davidoff with a black band. Davidoff rolls it in its own factory in the Dominican Republic from Nicaraguan leaf.
At launch, Davidoff described a 10-year-old Habano-seed Nicaraguan Rosado wrapper, a binder from Jalapa and filler from Estelí, Condega and the island of Ometepe. The Diadema, a double-tapered figurado, joined in 2014, and the Box Pressed blend in 2016.
That was a break from what Davidoff had been known for: milder cigars of Dominican tobacco under light Connecticut-seed wrappers. Davidoff still makes its milder Dominican blends in the white-band lines, such as the Davidoff Grand Cru.
Original or Box Pressed: two different blends
The Box Pressed is its own blend. It came out on March 21, 2016, in two sizes, a 5 x 48 Robusto and a 6 x 52 Toro. Davidoff swapped the Rosado wrapper for a darker Nicaraguan Habano Oscuro and moved its Estelí filler from viso to ligero, the leaf from the top of the plant, which carries the most nicotine. Davidoff said the change adds spice and strength. On its own intensity scale, out of 5, Davidoff rates the Box Pressed sizes 4.5 and the round sizes 4.
Critics split on whether that's an improvement:
- Cigar Coop scored the Box Pressed Toro 93, wrote that the changes "were like the midas touch," and put it at No. 8 on its 2016 Cigar of the Year countdown.
- Stogie Guys gave the Box Pressed Robusto 4.5 out of 5, half a point above its scores for the round sizes.
- halfwheel scored the Box Pressed Toro 86 in 2016, and said it seemed to "err a bit too much on strength, particularly in the middle third." Re-reviewed two years later, it scored 89, and the reviewer still wrote, "I'd still take the round version off the shelf."
Davidoff also says the Box Pressed Robusto draws more easily than the line's other sizes.
Here's how we'd choose. If you already like the round Davidoff Nicaragua and want more pepper and nicotine, try the Box Pressed. If you've never smoked the line, or you're sensitive to nicotine, start with a round size.
What the critics scored, size by size
Most sizes have been rated several times. The table gives the latest rating for each size we carry, the size's highest, and the other critics' scores with their years.
| Size | Cigar Aficionado, latest | Cigar Aficionado, highest | halfwheel | Cigar Coop | Stogie Guys |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Short Corona, 3 3/4 x 46 | 90 (2021) | 90 (2016, 2021) | 88 (2013) | Not listed | 4/5 (2016) |
Robusto, 5 x 50 | 86 (2017) | 91 (No. 21 of 2014) | Not listed | 91 (2013) | 4/5 (2015) |
Robusto in a tube, 5 x 50 | 87 (2018) | 87 | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed |
Toro, 5 1/2 x 54 | 90 (2020) | 95 (No. 3 of 2013) | Not listed | Not listed | 4/5 (2013) |
Diadema, 6 1/2 x 50 | 90 (2025) | 95 (No. 3 of 2022) | 89 (2014) | 93 (2015) | Not listed |
Box Pressed Robusto, 5 x 48 | 87 (2024) | 90 (2016, 2020) | Not listed | Not listed | 4.5/5 (2017) |
Box Pressed Toro, 6 x 52 | 88 (Cigar Insider, 2016) | 88 | 86 (2016); 89 (2018) | 93 (2016) | Not listed |
The pattern is steady scores around 90 for more than a decade, with two peaks. Cigar Aficionado named the Toro its No. 3 cigar of 2013 and called it "our favorite" of the three launch sizes. The Diadema has the deepest record in its database: eight ratings from 89 to 95 between 2014 and 2025, including No. 3 on the 2022 Top 25.
