Review roundup

Davidoff Nicaragua review: the ratings by size, and what the box-pressed blend changes

Twelve years of critic scores and Davidoff's own notes, size by size, for every Davidoff Nicaragua we carry.

The quick answer

Cigar Aficionado's ratings database holds 29 scores for Davidoff Nicaragua since 2013, from 86 to 95. Two sizes reached No. 3 on its Top 25: the Toro for 2013 and the Diadema for 2022. The latest score for each size we carry runs from 86 to 90. Critics' notes keep coming back to coffee, chocolate, nuts, wood and spice. They split on strength, from mild to medium-full, depending on the reviewer and the year. The Box Pressed is a different, stronger blend, and critics split on whether it's an improvement. If you're new to the line, start with a round size. The Diadema is the most-rated size in that database, with seven of its eight scores there at 90 or above.

In this article

What Davidoff Nicaragua is

Davidoff released Davidoff Nicaragua in the summer of 2013 in three sizes: Short Corona, Robusto and Toro. It was the company's first cigar made entirely from Nicaraguan tobacco and the first Davidoff with a black band. Davidoff rolls it in its own factory in the Dominican Republic from Nicaraguan leaf.

At launch, Davidoff described a 10-year-old Habano-seed Nicaraguan Rosado wrapper, a binder from Jalapa and filler from Estelí, Condega and the island of Ometepe. The Diadema, a double-tapered figurado, joined in 2014, and the Box Pressed blend in 2016.

That was a break from what Davidoff had been known for: milder cigars of Dominican tobacco under light Connecticut-seed wrappers. Davidoff still makes its milder Dominican blends in the white-band lines, such as the Davidoff Grand Cru.

Original or Box Pressed: two different blends

The Box Pressed is its own blend. It came out on March 21, 2016, in two sizes, a 5 x 48 Robusto and a 6 x 52 Toro. Davidoff swapped the Rosado wrapper for a darker Nicaraguan Habano Oscuro and moved its Estelí filler from viso to ligero, the leaf from the top of the plant, which carries the most nicotine. Davidoff said the change adds spice and strength. On its own intensity scale, out of 5, Davidoff rates the Box Pressed sizes 4.5 and the round sizes 4.

Critics split on whether that's an improvement:

  • Cigar Coop scored the Box Pressed Toro 93, wrote that the changes "were like the midas touch," and put it at No. 8 on its 2016 Cigar of the Year countdown.
  • Stogie Guys gave the Box Pressed Robusto 4.5 out of 5, half a point above its scores for the round sizes.
  • halfwheel scored the Box Pressed Toro 86 in 2016, and said it seemed to "err a bit too much on strength, particularly in the middle third." Re-reviewed two years later, it scored 89, and the reviewer still wrote, "I'd still take the round version off the shelf."

Davidoff also says the Box Pressed Robusto draws more easily than the line's other sizes.

Here's how we'd choose. If you already like the round Davidoff Nicaragua and want more pepper and nicotine, try the Box Pressed. If you've never smoked the line, or you're sensitive to nicotine, start with a round size.

What the critics scored, size by size

Most sizes have been rated several times. The table gives the latest rating for each size we carry, the size's highest, and the other critics' scores with their years.

What the critics scored, size by size
SizeCigar Aficionado, latestCigar Aficionado, highesthalfwheelCigar CoopStogie Guys
Short Corona, 3 3/4 x 46
90 (2021)
90 (2016, 2021)
88 (2013)
Not listed
4/5 (2016)
Robusto, 5 x 50
86 (2017)
91 (No. 21 of 2014)
Not listed
91 (2013)
4/5 (2015)
Robusto in a tube, 5 x 50
87 (2018)
87
Not listed
Not listed
Not listed
Toro, 5 1/2 x 54
90 (2020)
95 (No. 3 of 2013)
Not listed
Not listed
4/5 (2013)
Diadema, 6 1/2 x 50
90 (2025)
95 (No. 3 of 2022)
89 (2014)
93 (2015)
Not listed
Box Pressed Robusto, 5 x 48
87 (2024)
90 (2016, 2020)
Not listed
Not listed
4.5/5 (2017)
Box Pressed Toro, 6 x 52
88 (Cigar Insider, 2016)
88
86 (2016); 89 (2018)
93 (2016)
Not listed

The pattern is steady scores around 90 for more than a decade, with two peaks. Cigar Aficionado named the Toro its No. 3 cigar of 2013 and called it "our favorite" of the three launch sizes. The Diadema has the deepest record in its database: eight ratings from 89 to 95 between 2014 and 2025, including No. 3 on the 2022 Top 25.

Flavor: Davidoff's notes and the reviewers' notes

Davidoff describes the line in thirds: spice with wood and caramel at the start, then coffee and chocolate with some cream, then leather, spice and pepper at the end.

The critics' notes overlap with that. Coffee and chocolate turn up in Cigar Aficionado's notes from 2013 to 2025, nuts (hazelnut, walnut, almond) recur through 2023, and wood through 2020. A few notes Davidoff doesn't mention keep appearing too: floral notes on the early Toro and Short Corona, and coconut on the Robusto and Short Corona.

Where critics disagree is whether it tastes Nicaraguan. halfwheel's first review, in 2013, said Davidoff had blended a Nicaraguan cigar that "basically tastes very close to…well… a Davidoff." Cigar Coop's Robusto review that same summer found "a very Nicaraguan feel to it in terms of some of the bolder spices, nut, and natural tobacco flavors." In 2015, Stogie Guys found pepper "more like white pepper than the bold black pepper for which Nicaraguan tobacco is often known." If you're expecting a peppery, strong Nicaraguan cigar, the round sizes probably aren't it. By Davidoff's own account, the Box Pressed adds spice and strength.

How strong is it?

On our pages, strength means nicotine, the physical effect, and body means the weight and texture of the smoke. They're rated separately, and the cigar strength, body and flavor guide explains the difference.

The reviews don't agree on Davidoff Nicaragua's strength:

  • halfwheel's 2014 reviewer considered "every vitola to be medium in nicotine" and wrote that people often expect a strong Nicaraguan cigar and don't get one.
  • Stogie Guys found the Toro's "nicotine kick is minimal."
  • Cigar Coop rated the 2013 Robusto medium to full in strength, and the 2015 Diadema medium.
  • Cigar Aficionado's strength label has moved. Every rating from it and Cigar Insider from 2013 and 2014 says Medium, and every one since 2019 says Medium-Full.

Davidoff's own pages give no strength rating. They rate "intensity" out of 5, with the round sizes at 4, and the Robusto page describes the cigar's "full body."

The Box Pressed is where the reports agree it gets stronger. Cigar Coop found the Box Pressed Toro moved from medium to full by the end. halfwheel's 2016 reviewer, citing "the slow burn rate and what feels like a creeping amount of nicotine," got "fairly fatigued" in the last third.

We can't tell you why the reports differ. If you're sensitive to nicotine, eat first and start with the Short Corona, the shortest smoke in the line by Davidoff's own times.

Which size to buy

Which size to buy
SizeDimensionsDavidoff's smoking timeDavidoff list price (Oct. 30, 2026)List price at launch
3 3/4 x 46
20–35 min
$15.90
$9.90 (2013)
5 x 50
45–60 min
$21.50 ($20.80 without the tube)
$13.90 (2013)
5 1/2 x 54
60–80 min
$25.50
$16.90 (2013)
6 1/2 x 50
70–85 min
$27.50 ($110 for 4)
$17.90 (2014)
5 x 48
40–55 min
$20.90
$14.50 (2016)
6 x 52
55–75 min
$25.50 ($102 for 4)
$17.20 (2016)

Prices are Davidoff's, per cigar. Our online listings are a 5-pack of the Short Corona and 4-packs of the others.

Plan on more time than Davidoff lists. Reviewers took just under an hour on a Short Corona, 1 hour 50 minutes on a Diadema, and an average of 2 hours 20 minutes on a Box Pressed Toro.

What the reviews say about each size:

  • Short Corona. halfwheel's 2013 reviewer smoked all three launch sizes and found the Short Corona "easily the best," and Cigar Coop would start a newcomer on it before the Diadema. If you want the line's character in under an hour, this is the size.
  • Robusto Tubos. Cigar Aficionado's tasters found the tubed Robusto's draw "a bit firm" in 2018 (87). The plain Robusto made its Top 25 at No. 21 for 2014 but scored 86 in 2017, its most recent rating.
  • Toro. Critics disagree on this one. Cigar Aficionado named it No. 3 of 2013, while halfwheel's 2013 reviewer found it "clearly the least enjoyable flavor wise" of the three launch sizes. Ring gauge is the diameter in 64ths of an inch, so the Toro's 54 makes it the thickest of the regular round sizes. Robusto vs. Toro covers how to read the numbers.
  • Diadema. The most-rated size: eight of the 29 ratings, seven of them 90 or above, No. 3 of 2022, and a 93 from Cigar Coop. Not every reviewer is sold: halfwheel's 2014 reviewer scored it 89 and wrote that, apart from the Belicoso, they couldn't see themselves buying any size of the line. If you want the size with the longest record, it's this one. Give it an evening.
  • Box Pressed Robusto and Toro. For someone who already smokes the round line and wants it stronger (see above).

The 10th Anniversary Limited Edition

Davidoff shipped the Davidoff Nicaragua 10th Anniversary Limited Edition in July 2023: a 6 x 56 Gran Toro listed at $36 a cigar at release, in lacquered boxes of 12. Davidoff made 3,300 boxes for the U.S. It isn't a Nicaraguan puro. The wrapper is Ecuadorian, and one Estelí filler leaf spent six months in rum casks. Davidoff says the tobaccos' combined age is 45 years and calls the cigar "full-bodied."

The scores are close, 87 to 91, but the verdicts split:

  • Cigar Insider scored it 89 in 2023, finding maple syrup, pecan and "oaky rum barrel," but "some inconsistency on the draw."
  • halfwheel scored it 88 in 2023, found little nicotine, and said Davidoff's 4-of-5 intensity rating "seemed high." Re-reviewed a year later, it scored 91, and the reviewer wrote that "now is the time to revisit it."
  • Cigar Coop scored it 87 in 2024 with a value rating of "Not Recommended," writing that its flavors "were simply not as good as any of the vitolas in the original Davidoff Nicaragua" and that the burn needed work.

At its $36 release price, it's a cigar for an occasion. Going by the re-review, it improved with a year of age. Online it's an option on our Davidoff Nicaragua listing: choose "10th Anniversary LE."

Is Davidoff Nicaragua worth it?

Prices have risen a lot since launch. In 2013 the Short Corona listed at $9.90 and the Toro at $16.90. Davidoff now lists them at $15.90 and $25.50. The reviews of that time reflect the old prices. halfwheel was "extremely impressed with how aggressive the pricing is" and called the cigar "well worth the money." Stogie Guys "may be a little unconvinced the construction and complexity are outstanding enough to justify the exclusive price," though it still scored the Toro 4 out of 5.

Our answer depends on what you want. If you want Nicaraguan tobacco with Davidoff's construction and a record of scores around 90 for twelve years, it delivers that. If you want a strong, peppery Nicaraguan cigar, the reviews above give you reason to doubt the round sizes, and the Box Pressed is the stronger blend. Whether Davidoff as a brand is worth its prices is a bigger question, which our Davidoff Aniversario review takes up.

Questions about Davidoff Nicaragua

Is the Robusto Tubos the same cigar as the Robusto?

Davidoff sells the tube as a packaging option on its Robusto, the same 5 x 50 size, at $21.50 a cigar against $20.80 without the tube.

What is Davidoff Primeros Nicaragua?

A different, much smaller cigar: a 4⅛ x 34 petit panetela sold in tins of 6, with a Nicaraguan Habano wrapper, an Ecuadorian binder and Dominican and Nicaraguan filler. There's also a Primeros Nicaragua Maduro with a Mexican wrapper. Davidoff rates the Primeros Nicaragua 3 out of 5 on its intensity scale. Both are out of stock with us right now.

What happened to the 6 x 60, the Belicoso and the Culebra?

The Belicoso (2013) and the Culebra (2017) were limited releases, and the 6 x 60 came out in 2017. Davidoff's U.S. site doesn't list any of them today. You'll still find their reviews when you search the line, which is why some sizes in older articles don't match what's on shelves.

Sources

47 source links