Review roundup

Davidoff Grand Cru review: what the critics say, size by size

Thirty years of critic ratings, independent reviews and Davidoff's own notes, size by size.

The quick answer

Cigar Aficionado and Cigar Insider have scored the core Davidoff Grand Cru sizes 44 times since 1995, and every score falls between 84 and 90. The No. 2, the size they've rated most, scored 87 from Cigar Aficionado in February 2026. Reviewers put the current sizes mostly between mild and medium, and the reviews that mention construction mostly praise it. They split on flavor. Davidoff describes "oak wood, liquorice and fresh spice," while Cigar Aficionado's No. 2 notes keep coming back to wood, and four of them since 2016 report mustiness. Davidoff lists a No. 5 single at $16.40 and a Toro at $32.20 (checked October 30, 2026).

In this article

What Davidoff Grand Cru is

Grand Cru is one of the four lines in Davidoff's White Band collection. Davidoff places it in the Chateau Series, Zino Davidoff's first Davidoff-branded cigars.

It's a Dominican cigar. Davidoff lists Dominican filler and binder under an Ecuadorian wrapper, which reviewers identify as Ecuador Connecticut, Connecticut-seed leaf grown in Ecuador. Rating pages list a U.S. Connecticut Shade wrapper on Grand Cru through 2008 and an Ecuadorian one from 2009 on. Our Connecticut cigar guide covers what that leaf is and how it differs from U.S.-grown shade.

Davidoff's U.S. site lists five Grand Cru sizes:

What Davidoff Grand Cru is
SizeLength x ringDavidoff's smoking time
No. 5 (petit corona)
4 x 41
20 to 30 min
No. 3 (corona)
5 x 43
25 to 40 min
No. 2 (corona)
5 5/8 x 43
30 to 45 min
Robusto
5 1/4 x 52
45 to 65 min
Toro
6 x 54
60 to 80 min

Older ratings also cover a No. 1 and a No. 4, which Davidoff's U.S. site no longer lists. In 2024 Davidoff released a limited-edition Diademas Finas, a 6 3/4 x 50 figurado.

What the critics scored it, size by size

The Grand Cru reviews that rank in search each cover one size. Cigar Aficionado and Cigar Insider have rated the core sizes 44 times since 1995 (30 and 14).

What the critics scored it, size by size
SizeRatings (Cigar Aficionado + Cigar Insider)Score rangeLatest
No. 2
16 (1996 to 2026)
85 to 90
87, Cigar Aficionado, February 2026
No. 5
8 (1998 to 2021)
85 to 89
87, Cigar Aficionado, August 2021
No. 3
7 (1995 to 2009)
84 to 88
84, Cigar Aficionado, October 2009
No. 1 and No. 4 (no longer listed)
13 (1995 to 2015)
84 to 88
Not listed
Robusto
none
Not listed
Fine Tobacco Club, 90 (blind), September 2020
Toro
none
Not listed
no independent score we could verify

For the Robusto and Toro, we left out reviews published by cigar shops.

The scores barely move: across 16 ratings since 1996, the No. 2 has never gone above 90 or below 85. And neither magazine has rated the Robusto or the Toro, which Davidoff added in 2016.

The limited Diademas Finas, a different cigar from the core line, scored 92 from Cigar Insider in September 2024.

Flavor: Davidoff's notes and the reviewers' notes

Davidoff pitches Grand Cru at wine drinkers. It describes "oak wood, liquorice and fresh spice" and pairs the line with a Bordeaux aged in oak.

Cigar Aficionado's tasters find the wood: it's in about half of the eleven No. 2 notes since 2010. Among the rest, four things each turn up in four or five notes: something sweet, such as vanilla or dried apple; spice, from pepper to nutmeg; citrus; and mustiness. The February 2026 No. 2 note found a woody, herbal smoke with salted peanut and vanilla, and said the smoke "clashes a bit with the grassy finish." The 2021 No. 5 note found light notes of grass and toast, orange peel and a toasted almond finish.

The complaint that keeps coming back is mustiness. Four No. 2 notes (2016, 2017, 2021 and 2023) mention it, and two of them call the first puffs or the finish soapy. In 2023 the first puffs were musty, with mushroom and earth, before pepper, wood and lemon peel came through. Two independent reviewers found it in other sizes. Developing Palates noted "musty cedar" and "mushroom mustiness" in a No. 3, and Fine Tobacco Club found mustiness and mushroom in its blind Robusto, along with graham cracker, cinnamon, cedar and orange peel, some bitterness and "celery and vegetal notes" midway, and short finishes.

Vdg-cigars read the Robusto differently: buttery with some creaminess, with cedar, pistachio, vanilla and sweet licorice, Davidoff's own note. Cigar Sense, which profiles cigars rather than scoring them, names a different leading note for each size: savory for the No. 2, spicy for the No. 5, sweet for the Robusto and "dry / tannic" for the Toro.

How strong is it?

On our pages, strength means nicotine, the physical effect, and body means the weight and texture of the smoke. The cigar strength, body and flavor guide explains the difference.

Davidoff calls the tobaccos mild and pitches the line at novices and at smokers who want "a cultivated blend." Davidoff also gives each cigar its own intensity rating, out of 5, and every current Grand Cru size gets a 2. That's the maker's measure, separate from the critics' strength readings below. Cigar Aficionado's strength field on the No. 2 says mild-medium for every rating since 2019, mild for 2015 to 2017, and medium for 2010, 2011 and 2014. Its 2021 No. 5 rating says medium. Developing Palates found its No. 3 mild at the start, climbing to "slightly below medium" by the end.

Cigar Sense rates nicotine and puts every size it profiles at "medium nicotine intensity." Fine Tobacco Club's blind Robusto "picks up a bit more strength, teetering on the medium to full bodied side" midway, then settled back to medium.

Put together, the readings for the current sizes run from mild to medium, with one Robusto review going briefly past medium. If you've only smoked mild cigars, the Robusto is the current size where a reviewer reported the most strength or body (that review uses the two terms together).

Which size: No. 5, No. 2, Robusto or Toro

Each size gives you a different length, ring and smoking time.

No. 5. A 4-inch petit corona for a 20 to 30 minute break. Its ratings run 85 to 89. Of the sizes we carry, it's the least expensive at Davidoff's list price. We carry the Grand Cru No. 5 in a pack online.

No. 2. The longer corona, 30 to 45 minutes, and the size with the most ratings behind it. It's also the size most of the mustiness notes come from. We carry the Grand Cru No. 2 in a pack online.

Robusto and Toro. The thick sizes, 52 and 54 ring, for 45 to 80 minutes. Neither has a magazine rating (above). Robusto vs. Toro explains how ring gauge and length change a smoke. We carry the Grand Cru Toro and Robusto in packs, and the Robusto, Toro and No. 2 by the box.

The No. 3 shows up in searches too. It's a 5-inch corona between the No. 5 and the No. 2, and it's out of stock online right now.

Is Grand Cru worth the price?

At Davidoff's list prices, checked October 30, 2026, a single runs $16.40 for the No. 5, $23.80 for the No. 2, $27.90 for the Robusto and $32.20 for the Toro. That price has climbed. When Cigar Aficionado rated the No. 2 in April 2010, it listed the cigar at $13.10 and scored it 86. In February 2026 it listed it at $23.80 and scored it 87.

If you want a cigar that has rated about the same for decades, Grand Cru has that. If you expect the score to rise with the price, it hasn't. Two independent reviewers address value directly. Developing Palates called the line "pricey, but it delivers on flavor and construction." Vdg-cigars put the Robusto "maybe a little on the high side but not much."

Mustiness is the complaint that comes up most in the reviews above, so try a pack before a box. At Davidoff's list prices, the No. 5 five-pack, $82.00, is the least expensive Grand Cru pack. Whether Davidoff in general is worth the money is a separate question, and our Davidoff Aniversario review takes it on.

Questions about Davidoff Grand Cru

What is a No. 2 cigar?

At Davidoff, the number is just a size name inside a line. The Grand Cru No. 2 is a 5 5/8 x 43 corona. The Signature No. 2 is a different cigar, a 6 x 38 panetela. Check the line name before you compare reviews.

How is Grand Cru different from Aniversario?

Davidoff calls Grand Cru mild and Aniversario medium, with a creamy finish. Davidoff's own intensity rating, out of 5, is 2 for Grand Cru and 2.5 for most regular Aniversario sizes (3 for the No. 3). Aniversario is the line Davidoff launched for Zino Davidoff's 80th birthday in 1986, and our Davidoff Aniversario review covers it in full.

How is Grand Cru different from Signature?

Both are mild by Davidoff's own description, with Signature a step milder: Davidoff's intensity rating, out of 5, is 1.5 for the regular Signature sizes and 2 for Grand Cru. Davidoff describes Signature as creamy, with barley, cream and cedar, and pairs it with milk coffee. It describes Grand Cru as oak, liquorice and spice, and pairs it with Bordeaux.

Is Grand Cru the same as Chateau?

Davidoff describes its first Davidoff-branded cigars as the Chateau Series, including Grand Cru, so the two names belong to the same family.

Sources

16 source links