Compare cigars

Ashton ESG vs OpusX: Which Should You Choose?

A comparison of Ashton Estate Sun Grown and regular Fuente Fuente OpusX, using the 21 Year Salute and Robusto as the size pair.

At a glance

  • Choose Ashton ESG if Ashton's description of cedar and molasses is what draws you. Keep the size in mind: Cigar Aficionado's 2022 review of the 21 Year Salute emphasized wood, with some bitterness at the end.
  • Choose regular OpusX Robusto if cinnamon, red pepper and leather sound more appealing. Those are notes from Cigar Insider's March 2020 review of that size.
  • The caveat: the ESG 21 Year Salute and OpusX Robusto are the same length, but the ESG is wider. The reviews also come from different years, so they don't settle an overall winner.
  • If you're undecided, start with the size pair below. Check the exact cigar and its current price before choosing; the shared Fuente connection alone won't decide it for you.
In this article

Why Ashton ESG gets compared with OpusX

Both are Dominican puros: their wrapper, binder and filler are Dominican. ESG is made by the Fuentes, and the wrapper for both cigars comes from Chateau de la Fuente.

The reported wrapper distinction is sun-grown leaf for ESG and shade-grown leaf for regular OpusX. That distinction appears in a 2007 report on the 21 Year Salute's release. It doesn't establish an identical binder-and-filler recipe underneath.

ESG means Estate Sun Grown. This comparison concerns that line and regular Fuente Fuente OpusX, with the Robusto as the OpusX reference. Ashton VSG and the special OpusX releases are outside this comparison.

Call: ESG is worth considering alongside regular OpusX if the Dominican tobacco connection interests you. Choose between the named cigars rather than treating ESG as a substitute for any OpusX release.

A close size pair, with one mismatch

A close size pair, with one mismatch
CigarLengthRing gauge
Ashton ESG 21 Year Salute5¼ inches52
Regular Fuente Fuente OpusX Robusto5¼ inches50

The length matches. The ESG has two more ring-gauge points, so these aren't identical dimensions. This is the pair used here to keep the format reasonably close, without comparing an ESG of one size with an unrelated OpusX release.

Use the Robusto vs Toro comparison if you're also deciding between formats. The review findings below apply to the named cigars; they don't tell you how an ESG 24 Year Salute or another OpusX size will taste.

Call: a useful size pair, with the width difference kept visible.

Flavor: the maker's description and the size-specific reviews

Call: lean toward the description that fits your taste, while keeping the source and size attached to it.

Ashton describes ESG with cedar and molasses among its tasting notes. That's the maker's description of the line. Cigar Aficionado's October 2022 review of the 21 Year Salute emphasizes wood and slight bitterness at the end. If you're choosing ESG for sweetness, that less favorable finding matters.

For the regular OpusX Robusto, Cigar Insider's March 2020 review emphasizes cinnamon, red pepper and leather. It also includes graham cracker, a note that appears in Ashton's ESG description. There is some overlap, which makes a simple sweet-versus-spicy split too neat.

If the pepper-led Robusto description appeals to you, lean toward regular OpusX. If Ashton's ESG description appeals more, consider the 21 Year Salute with the less enthusiastic size-specific review in mind. Neither set of notes promises the same experience from every cigar in the line.

Strength: don't assume ESG will be mild

Call: don't choose ESG solely because you expect it to feel weaker.

Ashton labels ESG's strength Medium-Full. Cigar Insider's March 2020 OpusX Robusto review also uses Medium-Full, while Cigar Aficionado's October 2022 ESG 21 Year Salute review uses Medium. Keep each label attached to its source rather than turning them into a nicotine ranking.

For the terminology, see cigar strength, body and flavor. A preference for one flavor description doesn't establish which cigar will feel stronger to you.

Choosing between them

Call: let the documented flavor profile guide your preference, then check the exact size and current offer.

If you're comparing prices, compare the sizes you actually intend to buy. Don't pay more for ESG on an assumption that its Fuente connection makes it the same cigar as OpusX. And don't pay more for an OpusX release whose reviews you're borrowing from a different size or line.

For the OpusX side of this comparison, use the regular Fuente Fuente OpusX product page and select Robusto. Keep the other releases on that page separate from this choice.

About this page

The comparison uses maker information and dated, size-specific reviews. The ESG review is from Cigar Aficionado's October 2022 issue; the OpusX Robusto review is from Cigar Insider's March 2020 issue. The sources below identify each record.

Sources

6 source links