Cigar guide
Cigar plume vs. mold: how to tell, and what to do
White stuff on the wrapper: what it could be, what to check, and what to do if you can't tell.
The quick answer
Plume, also called bloom, is the trade's name for a fine white powder on an aged cigar, traditionally explained as oils from the tobacco. Mold can be white and powdery too, and Tobacconist University says neither the look nor the feel of a white substance alone proves it's plume. Fuzz, color or a stain can point to mold, but nothing you can do at home clears a cigar. If you can't tell, treat it as mold: set the cigar apart and don't smoke it. A cigar with mold on it gets thrown out, and the humidor gets cleaned.
In this article
What is cigar plume?
Plume, also called bloom, is the trade's name for a fine white powder that can show up on the wrapper of an aged cigar. The traditional explanation is that oils from the tobacco work their way through the wrapper and crystallize on the surface.
A standard cigar glossary calls it a natural part of aging and says it brushes off without leaving a mark, while mold has color and stains the wrapper. Several retail guides go further and call plume a sign that a cigar is aging well.
Is cigar plume real, or is it just mold?
Nobody has settled it, and both sides claim more than the evidence shows.
Tobacconist University, which certifies tobacconists, says modern examination has challenged some of the traditional explanations. Its advice is practical: don't assume an unidentified substance is harmless just because it's white, powdery or granular.
The people who say plume is always mold often point to a cigar forum's lab tests from 2017. In a first round, ten cigars chosen from samples its members suspected were mold or plume went to an outside lab, and all ten came back as mold. A second round of twelve samples, most of them pipe tobacco, left out anything with obvious fuzzy growth, and it found mold on one and bacteria on the rest. That's a small set of samples from a cigar forum, and the first round wasn't peer reviewed. A molecular microbiologist who wrote about the first round in 2019 said it had holes, starting with the fact that mold spores settle on almost any organic material, so finding mold on a cigar isn't surprising. He still doubted plume, calling it possible in theory, especially on a darker wrapper, but saying it wouldn't look round, even or fuzzy.
The company that markets Cuban cigars has a third view. Its care guide calls bloom a white, powdery mold that shows up after a sudden rise in humidity, says it's a sign the cigar is alive and well, and says to brush it off.
Our advice: plume may exist, but nobody has shown you can tell it from mold at home. Treat any white growth you can't identify as possible mold.
How to tell plume from mold
You usually can't, not for certain. The common tests can point toward mold, but passing all of them doesn't prove a cigar is clean.
| The test | What guides say | What it can tell you |
|---|---|---|
Powder or fuzz | Plume is a fine powder; mold is fuzzy or webby | Fuzz points to mold. Powder doesn't clear it, because mold can be powdery too |
White or colored | Plume is white; mold has color | Green or blue growth points to mold. White doesn't clear it |
Does it brush off? | Plume brushes off clean; mold sticks or stains | A stain points to mold. A clean wipe doesn't settle it |
Where it is | Plume stays on the wrapper; mold grows at the foot | Growth at the foot points to mold. Mold grows on the wrapper too |
Even or spotted | Guides disagree: one says plume covers the whole cigar, another that it forms tiny dots | Not much, since they can't agree |
Smell | Mold smells musty; plume has no bad smell | A musty smell points to mold. No smell doesn't clear it |
If you can't tell, treat it as mold: set the cigar apart and don't smoke it.
What cigar mold looks like
Cigar mold can be white, gray, green or blue, and it's often fuzzy, woolly or powdery. It can grow on the wrapper, under the band, at the foot (the end you light) or inside the filler, so check all of those places you can reach.
Other spots that aren't plume or mold
Some marks are part of the leaf itself.
Tooth is the grain of a less smooth wrapper: tiny bumps that are pockets of oil. You'll see it most often on Cameroon-seed wrapper, which our guide to cigar wrappers covers. The bumps become the small white dots in the ash, though other tobaccos can leave those dots with no tooth you can see.
Water spots, sometimes called sun spots, are flat, pale marks in the leaf, generally put down to moisture droplets marking it. One trade guide calls them cosmetic and says they won't appear while cigars sit in a humidor, since the tobacco is done growing and curing.
Anything that sits on the surface goes back to the table above.
Can you smoke a cigar with plume?
Not if you can't tell what it is. Treat it as mold: don't smoke it. Several guides say to brush plume off and light the cigar, but brushing off what you can see may not remove what's in the tobacco, and there's no reliable way to restore a moldy cigar.
White mold gets the same answer as any other color.
What to do with a moldy cigar
- Set apart any cigar you suspect. If you can't confirm what's on it, treat it as mold: keep it apart and don't smoke it.
- Throw out the ones with mold on them. Don't brush them off or try to dry them out.
- Look over the other cigars in the box and the humidor. Separate any that look suspect.
- Move the cigars that look clean somewhere else while you deal with the humidor. A sealed container with a two-way humidity pack will hold them; see keeping cigars without a humidor.
A cigar that's only too wet (soft and swollen, with nothing growing on it) is a different problem, and do cigars go bad covers it.
How to clean mold out of a humidor
Empty it, wipe it down, let it dry completely and fix what caused the mold. Tobacconist University calls its own version of these steps a best-effort approach: no treatment guarantees every bit of mold is gone, especially in porous wood.
- Take everything out: cigars, trays, dividers and the humidifier. Look over the inside and the accessories for mold or moisture.
- Wipe the inside with 70% isopropyl alcohol on a clean cloth. Glass, metal and many plastics clean easily. Use it sparingly on Spanish cedar, and never pour it on the wood.
- Leave the humidor open in a well-ventilated spot until it's completely dry and the alcohol smell is gone. Keep it away from flames.
- Fix the cause: humidity set too high, condensation or a dirty humidifier. Make sure the humidifier is clean and working. Replace anything you can't actually clean.
- Return the clean cigars only once the humidor is clean, dry and holding steady humidity.
Keep watching for the mold to come back. Cleaning the surface may not reach mold that's deep in the wood or widespread, and the affected wooden parts may then need replacing.
Cleaning guides don't agree on the details. Some have you sand the cedar first, and Tobacconist University's steps don't call for it. One guide wants alcohol at 91% or stronger. Some say to throw out the humidifier every time, where our rule is the one in step 4. Several cleaning guides have you re-season the box afterward, and a humidor that has dried out needs seasoning again. How to season a humidor has the steps.
Why cigars get moldy, and how to prevent it
Too much moisture: humidity set too high, condensation, or a humidifier that's been neglected. For the numbers to hold, see the right humidity for cigars.
Mold can also come from the factory, on cigars packed with too much moisture in the leaf, so a cigar can arrive moldy even when your humidor is fine. Look over new cigars before they go in with the rest, especially if the packaging looks damp or the tobacco seems unusually moist.
Tobacconist University says thick, oily wrappers, including some Broadleaf, deserve particular attention, though oil alone doesn't mean mold will develop. Oily tobaccos are also the ones plume guides say are more likely to get plume.
The rest is upkeep. Good air circulation helps, especially in larger humidors. If your humidifier takes water, use distilled. And open the humidor and look at the cigars themselves regularly.
Frequently asked questions
Can moldy cigars be saved?
No. There's no reliable way to restore a moldy cigar. Some guides suggest wiping it with alcohol and putting it in the freezer, but Tobacconist University says to throw it out rather than treat it for smoking.
How do you remove white spots from a cigar wrapper?
Brushing can take off what's on the surface, but it won't tell you what it was. Tooth and water spots are part of the leaf, so there's nothing to remove.
Can a cigar get moldy?
Yes. Mold is fungal growth, and it can develop on tobacco when there's too much moisture.
