Cigar guide

Gifts for Cigar Lovers: How to Choose

Start with what they already smoke, then let their experience and the occasion narrow it down.

The quick answer

The best gift for a cigar lover starts with what they already smoke. If you can find that out, buy the same cigar or another line from the same maker. If you can't, a sampler usually gives them some variety. A gift pack works too once you've checked what's in it. Someone new to cigars may do better with a small pack and a way to cut and light them. For someone who has everything, look for something they're unlikely to have bought themselves, or a better version of a tool they use every day. Let the occasion set what you spend.

In this article

Start by finding out what they smoke

When someone asks me what to buy, I ask questions before I recommend anything. What else do they smoke? When do they smoke? What's the occasion, and why now?

You'll be answering those for someone else, and if you don't smoke cigars, the first one is the hard one. You can try to learn what they smoke without spoiling the surprise. Look at the band on a cigar they've left out, or on an empty box. Ask whoever they smoke with. Write down the name on the band, and the size if it's printed on the box, because one cigar name often comes in several sizes.

Try to learn how often they smoke, too. If they smoke several cigars a week, a box makes sense. If they smoke a few a year, consider something smaller, since a box needs somewhere to live.

If you know what they smoke

Buy that cigar, or another size of it. You already know they like it.

If you'd rather have them try something new, stay with the same maker, and look at its strength rating first if the maker publishes one, because a different line from the same maker can be a different blend.

I might suggest something a little fuller if they have the experience, or if something else they smoke is about that full. That's just my experience.

Online we sell boxes and multi-cigar packs. A single cigar is an in-store purchase, so call first to see whether we have it.

If you don't know what they smoke

Buy a sampler. It gives them several cigars to try, so the gift doesn't rest on one guess.

A sampler usually mixes cigars, from one maker or from several. A gift pack is packaged for giving and its contents vary, so check the listing before you buy it, and call us if the listing doesn't say.

If you've got a maker's name to go on, even without the cigar, a pack from that maker keeps you with a name they already smoke. Padrón's 1964 Natural gift pack is one we carry.

If they're new to cigars

If they're still deciding whether they like cigars, consider a small pack over a box. There's less to finish and less to store.

They'll also need a way to cut and light them, so add a cutter and a lighter if they don't own them.

Which cigar comes down to the two things I ask about any first cigar, and our guide to smoking a cigar goes through them. It also covers the cut, the light and the first puffs, so it's worth sending along with the gift.

If they already have everything

They still smoke, so cigars are still on the table. Look for one they're unlikely to have bought for themselves.

When I'm celebrating, I reach for Davidoff's Limited Editions or Fuente's limited, hard-to-get lines.

For a limited release sold as a set, one option we carry is The Opus X Story from Fuente. Its product page lists what's in it.

The other route is a better version of something they reach for every day. Look at the cutter or lighter they use now, and buy up from there.

Accessories worth giving

A cutter. Smokers have preferences among straight cuts, V-cuts and punches, so look at what they use now. If you can't tell, the types of cigar cuts will help you decide.

A lighter. How they smoke decides this one, and our lighter guide goes through the options. A butane lighter needs butane. If they don't have any at home, plan on a can to go with it.

An ashtray. Look for rests wide enough to hold a cigar. If they smoke with friends, get one with more than one rest.

A case. This is for someone who takes cigars to the golf course or on trips. Check how many it holds and whether it's sized for the cigars they smoke, since some cases come in a size made for thicker cigars.

If they're starting out, a set that pairs a cutter with a lighter covers both, and we carry a few. Add one to a sampler and you've built your own gift set.

Should you buy a humidor?

Consider one if they don't already own one and they keep more cigars than they'll smoke soon. Ask first if you can.

A humidor with an unfinished cedar interior needs seasoning before any cigars go in, so don't pack cigars inside it as a surprise. For sizes and types, see how a humidor works.

How much to spend

Let the occasion decide. For me, a $50 cigar is justified by the moment, a wedding, a birth or a graduation, not by the cigar itself. And for me, a cigar for the golf course or yard work, or to share with people who may not smoke cigars, doesn't need to be the high-end one.

For a sense of range, our online prices on November 8, 2026 were $65.00 for the Caldwell 5 Cigar Sampler, $79.95 for the Diamond Crown Royal Sampler and $259.95 for The Opus X Story.

Holding it and handing it over

If you buy early, the cigars need looking after until the day. Our guide to storing cigars without a humidor covers a box you're holding as a gift.

You must be 21 or older to buy from us. At checkout you can choose Self Pickup in Jessup, collect it yourself and hand it over. For anything else, call us at 410-799-2094.

All purchases are final under our Terms.

Sources

2 source links